HPPSC Conducted Naib Tehsildar 2017 Prelims on 20th August, 2017 and on 21th August they Released the Official Answer Keys.
You can Download Official Answer keys form HPPSC's website.
You can Download Official Answer keys form HPPSC's website.
Or
You can Download Here
Official Note : OBJECTIONS, IF ANY, (ALONGWITH DOCUMENTARY PROOF) IN RESPECT OF KEY RECEIVED IN THE OFFICE OF THE COMMISSION FROM THE CANDIDATE(S) IN PERSON / BY POST/ THROUGH COURIER WITHIN SEVEN DAYS WILL ONLY BE ENTERTAINED i.e. UPTO 27-08-2017 ON THE PROFORMA ENCLOSED AT END. NO E-MAIL/OTHER MODE OF RECEIPT OF OBJECTIONS WILL BE ENTERTAINED.
I have added a Poll so don't forget to take part in it.
Poll :
Scoring 82.
ReplyDeleteObjection in 2 questions only
Series D me ganga of south ka ans krishna dia h.. godavari should be ans
And sampriti exercise . India bangladesh should b ans..
Bhai yahan itne attempt ni hote jitna aapka score hai.... congratulationscongratulations bhai
DeleteKnown to devout Hindus as Daksina Ganga (“Ganges of the South”), the Kaveri River is celebrated for its scenery and sanctity in Tamil literature, and its entire course is considered holy ground. The river is also important for its irrigation canal projects.
DeleteBhi g itni fadu preparation kaise koi books to suggest kro modern history or HP gk k liye
Delete72
ReplyDelete72.5
ReplyDelete68.25
ReplyDelete62.5 SC. Wat r the chances ?
ReplyDeletemains bhi nikal jayega bas bhar do paper
Delete69
ReplyDeleteobjection in 3 question SERIES C.. Que 37 Godavri is known as Ganga of South.
ReplyDeleteQue 47 Sampriti exercise India - Bangladesh not russia
Que 48 Sanskrit award 2016 was given to Maha Chakri and Prof. George Carodna
....Scoring 72.75 after correction of mistakes in answer keys.
Maha chakri was winner of 2015 presented to both in 2016 mine also wrong did maha chakri
Deletedamn..commission wale hpas ki jgah naib main tricky question daal rahe hai :P
DeleteSeries A .Q49.....what to choose...right or wrong codes....
ReplyDelete60 sc any chance???
ReplyDeleteMy score 63 general
ReplyDeleteFRBM ACT 2003
ReplyDeleteSampriti exercise
ReplyDelete73.. error in 3 questions
ReplyDelete65.75 general . are there any chances khadhubhai DO REPLY !!
ReplyDeleteYess. Far and away the best prize that life has to offer is the chance to work hard at work worth doing.
DeleteKnown to devout Hindus as Daksina Ganga (“Ganges of the South”), the Kaveri River is celebrated for its scenery and sanctity in Tamil literature, and its entire course is considered holy ground. The river is also important for its irrigation canal projects.
ReplyDeleteScoring 79 with v-, 83 are right and yes I too have objection in above three. Questions....
ReplyDeleteCongrats
Deletealready u r eti why wasting time on nt. go for HAS instead.
DeleteThere is huge difference between ETI and Nt,ETI is nothing in front of Nt.even iam in gazetted class2 post.But Naib tehsildar is best job ..even it is better than ETO.NT is an administrative officer ,whereas ETI or ETO are not.
DeleteSo u think HAS is below NT.... Even after clearing NT u will try for HAS,isn't it. So why waste resources of state and ur time. Let someone who is unemployed/ in pvt sector get selected as u r already getting a regular govt job. if u can understand my point its ok if u dont then also it doesnt matter. gudluck for NT. peace.
DeleteIf trying for better is wastage of time than I am wasting. I am wasting my time on my aim and ambition. Dude this is not good to say such thing, if someone is doing good you should appreciate, if you did the same thing I will appreciate you for sure. We are here for discussion and share our experiences not for these things.
DeleteIf you think mine efforts are the wastage of resource and time than sorry, I will try hard to get better and everybody should do.
Hello Radhika....congrats on getting through allied services.
Deleteplease can you guide me for NT mains hindi paper as it is similar to allied mains hindi paper ..you have scored very good marks in Hindi (121/150)
How to prepare it religiously and which sources need to follow , I am very weak in Hindi and my grammar is also weak(while writing I do lots of spelling mistake}
thanks in advance
Did Gurkha returned the territories to Kahlur or did they kept it with them abd returned by British.. Blokhra me kuch clear ni hai
ReplyDeleteyup they did return the winning territories to kehlur state , they both were allies and they had the agreement .
DeleteIn wonderland page 444 : the gurkhas continued to occupy Bilaspur and other hill sates till 1814.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteIt's not kahlur it's kutlehar if you have akash himachal darpan go to page 113 its given clearly gorkhas
DeleteI mean can you point out specifically where it is written that did return the land
DeleteOk.... Its kutlehar.. Right
DeleteKhudabhai I get 68.50 (general) after objection hv any chance
Deletehttps://www.britannica.com/place/Kaveri-River Cauvery is the right answer
ReplyDeletegodavari is called dakshin ganga(south ganga), while kaveri is known as ardh ganga (semi ganga)
DeleteNcert class 9th book-contemporary india , chapter 3
http://ncert.nic.in/ncerts/l/iess103.pdf
DeleteIndia - A comprehensive Geography - D. R. Khullar 3rd edition
DeletePage Number 108 Last Paragraph : Godavari = Vridha Ganga or Dakshina Ganga
Page Number 109 2nd Paragraphy : Kaveri = Dakshina Ganga or The Ganga of the South.
Delete
Tamil Nadu State Board Book 10th Geography Page Number 123 Should clear the doubt of all the candidates
Tamil Nadu State Board Book 10th Geography
ncert 11th 3rd chapter page 21. on drainage mentions godavri as dakshin ganga
DeleteGodavari is south ganga and Cauvery is the Ganges of south
ReplyDeleteAsa bhi kuch concept h kya??? Ye kahan likha h bhai??
Delete9th class NCERT says godavari is dakshin ganga.. please source btao jahan ye concept dia h. ( south ganga and ganga of south is different????)) never heard .. please source ???
Yes two different Things
DeleteIndia - A comprehensive Geography - D. R. Khullar 3rd edition
Page Number 108 Last Paragraph : Godavari = Vridha Ganga or Dakshina Ganga
Page Number 109 2nd Paragraphy : Kaveri = Dakshina Ganga or The Ganga of the South.
Tamil Nadu State Board Book 10th Geography Page Number 123
aab to aapni prediction batao sir ....acc to official ans key ..kuch clarity hogi.....
ReplyDeleteAccording to sanad of 1815 AD Which area was returned to raja of simaur - Kayaar -Da -dun. But it was restored to him in 1833
ReplyDeleteYeah but sand was granted in 1815 so it's like legal document according to its provision in 1833 kyarda dun was returned it's like companies act 2013 according to which new companies form in 2017 as well
DeleteLXXVIll.— Sanad conferring on llaja Fateh Singli (or Parkash)
Deletethe lands of Sirmur, dated 21st September 1815 .
LXXIX.— Sanad conferring on Raja Fateh Parkash of Nahan the
lands of the Kiarda Dun, dated 6th September 1833
Refer the below link kyarda dun was given in separate sanad https://archive.org/stream/in.ernet.dli.2015.206801/2015.206801.A-Collection_djvu.txt
This more authentic than any other book.
71.50
ReplyDeleteAny chance
Full chance........
DeleteThanks bhai
DeleteAny insight on this question.
ReplyDeleteif anyone hv detail about Reet marriage plz share
ReplyDeletecut off kitna jayega general valo k liye ...
ReplyDeleteGen 60-65 in
ReplyDeletei got 57.. ..no chance
ReplyDeleteMay be be +
Delete65.75 gen is there any chance
DeleteFull Chance!!!
Delete64 after objection general
ReplyDeleteGUYS If they ask Ganges of south then its Godavari and if they ask Ganges of south India then its Kaveri
ReplyDelete59 ...gen...game over or not?
ReplyDeletenot yet.
DeleteIt is ganges of south not ganges of south india so appropriate answer will be godavari
ReplyDeleteGodavari is not ganges of south, but south ganga or dakshin ganga only.. Kaveri is ganges of south
DeleteDo see on hindi side version also.....and ncert class 9....all doubt will be clear....
DeleteBhai south india aur south ma difference ha
DeleteCauvery is ganges of south india not ganges of south ok ganges of south is godavari and ganges of south india is cauvery
DeleteThere is difference between them ganges of south and ganges of south india
ReplyDeleteGot 54.5 gen..any chance
ReplyDeleteGodavari hai Dakshin Ganga -- given on page 27 chapter 3 of 11th class ncert.. samprirti to obvious hai bangaldesh hoga... scoring 69.50 in general category...
ReplyDeleteGetting 68.5. Is there chances for mains. And i think three question are objectionable. FRBM act, dikshin ganga and sampriti.
ReplyDeleteQ-105(D series): Aren't Influent drainage, Bangar soil, Doabs are also the features of Ganga Plain?
ReplyDeleteIf not then please clarify.
Yes of course. This question shld also be considered for objections.OBC 61.any chance.
DeleteThe main pic of this question is doab.....
DeleteDoab she bangar....ganga known for more khadar....
DeleteBangar region or this soil dominated areas refers to the sandy tract
Deleteof north-western India and eastern parts of current Pakistan bordering
India.
Doabs are also the features of these regions so Indo-Satluj is the
right answer.
Doabs are also the features of Ganga Plain but not bangar soils
dominated region.
Ganges is having not influent flow as compared to the indo satluj and indo satluj are continously doab and bhanghar
ReplyDeleteInfluent flow is anything flowing in, as a tributary. Then how Ganges not having influent flow?
Deletecutt off will be
ReplyDeletegen 62-64
obc 52-54
sc 50 -52
st 55-57
Where 55 to 61
DeleteQ-54(D series): Acc. to Balokhra Chamba conquered Lahaul in 600 A.D(Page no.600) and Raja of Kullu was Sansar Pal from 600 to 650 A.D (Page no.569). Then how Rudar Pal is the answer?
ReplyDeletePlease clarify.
sahi keh rahe ho bhai
Delete56 in general??????????
ReplyDelete52 in OBC ... do i hv a chance 4 appearing in mains
ReplyDeletetough call bhai
DeleteEach candidate have to fill objection or commission will itself correct itself if found any discrepancy in answer key plz clarify
ReplyDeleteMere 66 mrk (Ur) BN the h.aur m sure Hun k pre clear ho jayega. Jo Apne marks 80-90 bta rhe h, ya to. Wo jooth bol rhe h ya phir wo sapne dekh the h. Paper tough tha. 30-35 que easy the. Isliye sbko paper easy of that lg rha h aur is baar to negative marking b h. Kuch ek ho skte h jinke marks 80+ honge. But 90 wala to shayd hoga hi ni.
ReplyDeleteGuys any insight on below fact
ReplyDeletehttps://archive.org/stream/in.ernet.dli.2015.206801/2015.206801.A-Collection_djvu.txt
LXXVIll.— Sanad conferring on llaja Fateh Singli (or Parkash)
the lands of Sirmur, dated 21st September 1815 .
LXXIX.— Sanad conferring on Raja Fateh Parkash of Nahan the
lands of the Kiarda Dun, dated 6th September 1833
Kirada dun wasn't conferred to sirmaur raja in sanad 1815 but in different one.
English : Ganges of the South
ReplyDeleteHindi : दक्षिण की गंगा Or दक्षिण भारत की गंगा Not दक्षिण गंगा ( Mind the difference Here)
Ganges of the South : Kaveri (Or One can also Say South Indian Ganga - Reason : Kaveri River is celebrated for its scenery and sanctity in Tamil literature, and its entire course is considered holy ground.)
Dakshin Ganga (दक्षिण गंगा = the South Ganges river) : Godavari ( Even Wiki says In terms of length, catchment area and discharge, the Godavari river is the largest in peninsular India and had been dubbed as the 'Dakshina Ganga' – the South Ganges river - Its a Name given to it on the basis of its size and catchment areas)
Another Fact is that I will suggest you Guys to look the Indian Physical Map and apply some simple logic that Godavari don't lie in Exact South India, it flows through Maharashtra (48.6%), Telangana (18.8%), Andhra Pradesh (4.5%), Chhattisgarh (10.9%), Madhya Pradesh (10.0%), Odisha. SO it doesn't lie even in far south. U can also check location of Kaveri in Map.
This Question is Clear I think NO more discussion is required Because this is the problem of Interpretation of any individual. So Interpret in right manner. English Version will stand. And commission is not fool they going to review but when they make key are almost correct in doing so except some rare wrong answers.
Kaveri is the Right Answer.
Samapriti - India & Bangladesh.
Rolling plan - One year
Yes kaveri is the right answer. Because people marked their answer as godavari, they are hell bent to make it right.
DeleteWhat about FRBM act
Deletecauvery - ganges of south india not ganges of south.
Deletemark the difference respected khadu sir
if english language prevails then it would be godavri sir
Delete@ Dev Aree bhai Ek bar Dobara padh lo yar jo maine likha hai. I have witten in both the language so that the interpretation is not wrong.
DeleteThere is a Difference in South Ganga (दक्षिण गंगा) and Ganga of the South (दक्षिण की गंगा Or दक्षिण भारत की गंगा) .
Now check the Question Paper and they have asked : Which river is called as the Ganges of the SOUTH ? not South Ganga
South Ganga or South Ganges is Godavari
Ganges of the SOUTH or Ganga of the South is Kavri. U can even understand the Ganges of the South India and That is Kaveri for its religious importance.
good chances
DeleteIs there any difference between Ganga of Himlaya's or Himalya's Ganga.? How will u interpret this @Khadubhai
DeleteVery good question.I request all to adopt a rational approach rather than seeing from the point of view of ur answer
DeleteI have marked Kaveri as answer but the correct answer as per me should be Godavari
U can check Hindi translation of same question for more clarity where Ganges of south is translated as Dakshin ki Ganga.Now what is the difference between Dakshin ki Ganga and Daksini Ganga??
https://www.quora.com/Which-river-is-called-the-Ganga-of-south...
DeletePraveen Thakur n Anurag Thakur
DeleteDakshin Ganga is a Name Given to Godavari. It is Name Given to it, like Ganga itself is called by many other names. Reason for calling Godavari as Dakshin Ganga is : The Godavari is the largest Peninsular river. It rises from the slopes of the Western Ghats in the Nasik district of Maharashtra. Its length is about 1500 km. It drains into the Bay of Bengal. Its drainage basin is also the largest among the peninsular rivers. The basin covers parts of Maharashtra (about 50 per cent of the basin area lies in Maharashtra), Madhya Pradesh, Odisha and Andhra Pradesh. The Godavari is joined by a number of tributaries such as the Purna, the Wardha, the Pranhita, the Manjra, the Wainganga and the Penganga. The last three tributaries are very large. Because of its length and the area it covers, it is also known as the ‘Dakshin Ganga’.
Now there is differnce in a Name Dashin Ganga and the direction mentioned Dakshin. Dakshin is Ganga means Ganga in the South not the Name while Dakshin Ganga is name given to it because of its similarity with Ganga for being lasted river, larger catchment area, more tributaries, its leanth and area covered.
While Kaveri is called Ganges of the South becasue of religious belief attachec to it,they consider it as much as holy North Indians consider Ganga. Another fact is that Kareri lies in far south in comarison to Godavari.
Proof : India - A comprehensive Geography - D. R. Khullar 3rd edition
Page Number 108 Last Paragraph : Godavari = Vridha Ganga or Dakshina Ganga
Page Number 109 2nd Paragraphy : Kaveri = Dakshina Ganga or The Ganga of the South. Very very clearly mentioned. This is Standard book followed for UPSC, Graduate and Postgarduate studies.
No one can Question this Question now on the ground of English Version of the Question : Which of the river is called 'Geanges of the south' ? Very clearly Kaveri is written so called Ganges of the South. While Godavari is called or known as Vridha Ganga or Dakshina Ganga.
Debate ends here, those still doubtful they can send objections no one bothers about that but truth is HPPSC also puts the options from varified sources so this Answer of Kaveri will stay.
Praveen bro Quora, facebook, whatsapp, twitter these are not considered authentic proof for such exams. Even Wikipedia is not considered.
DeleteI have mention the evidence from : India - A comprehensive Geography - D. R. Khullar 3rd edition
Page Number 108 Last Paragraph : Godavari = Vridha Ganga or Dakshina Ganga
Page Number 109 2nd Paragraphy : Kaveri = Dakshina Ganga or The Ganga of the South.
Tamil Nadu State Board Book 10th Geography Page Number 123 Should clear the doubt of all the candidates
DeleteTamil Nadu State Board Book 10th Geography
Khadubhai rehne do, ye nahi manenge kyuki inhone godavari mark kiya hai :)
DeleteYupp@anonymous. 1 number ki kafi value Hoti h. Mere 66 se 65 ho jayenge..
DeleteAs answer key has some error,this question may be one of them? Age answer key m Godavari this btata hota to b kya itna debate hona tha?
Guys getting 58 under SC category. Is there chances of writing mains???
ReplyDeleteWorld Sanskrit Award for the year 2015 - Princess Maha Chakri Sirindhorn
ReplyDeleteWorld Sanskrit Award for the year 2016 - George Cardona
62. OBC is there any chance?? for mains
DeleteKhadu Bhai ji merit kitni tk jayegi??? Wht u think ?? 65 or 70 fr general....
ReplyDelete70.25 (GENERAL)
ReplyDeleteSHOULD I START PREPARING FOR MAINS ?
Yupppp Bhai in safe zone according to mine experience..merit somewhere btwn 65to 68
DeletethoS time only 1 qstn sampriti is wrong in ans key....paper standard good...Wht u think sir?? Merit 65 or 70???
ReplyDelete60 marks with o.b.c category.. can i clear pre with this score???
ReplyDeleteAllied service ki notification kab tak hogi please share
ReplyDeleteScoring 79.5 general
ReplyDeleteAny chances sir?
Toda tribe ?????pls make it clear ....
ReplyDeleteToda tribe live in Nilgiri Hills. These Hills covers the border areas Kerala, Karnataka & Tamilnadu.
DeleteKhadu Bhai the correct answer is Tamil Nadu
DeleteThere was a question where in it was asked which country India defeated to win Asia Cup.
DeleteIf you apply logic India has defeated all the four countries given in options to win the cup.It was in finals that India defeated China .
Todo Tribes live in Nilgiri plateau and it is spread in 3 states of Kerela, Karnataka and Tamilnadu. Tamilnadu is not in the options so its obvious that Part of Nilgiri plateau lies in Kerela as well. So this is right answer.
DeleteKhadubhai please guide 55 SC CATEGORY HAVE ANY CHANCE FOR MAINS
ReplyDeleteLast time NT Mai general ki 4 post thi or cut off 82 gyi thi or paper easy tha iss baar k paper se.
ReplyDeleteNow look iss baar 3 factor hai
1 paper tough hai
2 -ve marking hai
3 post jyada hai
Cut off for general 65 +- 2 ki aas paas rehni chahiye or polling scenario se b yhi clear ho rha. Baki khadubhai clear krege ab.
Agreed
DeleteCut off 100% 65 se niche rhega. Those who are getting above 65 should start preparing for mains
ReplyDeleteMadam,You are absolutely right...But little apprehension of Gen 69.OBC 63.Let's see but Khadu Sir predictions goes forthright.But cracking NT exam is definitely our of the box attempt.moreover I agree with some guys days NT is better than ETO cos Admn is always superior to others.
DeletePlease can some one guide me for NT mains Hindi paper ...how to prepare it and basic books need to follow....
ReplyDeleterange forest officer ka xam kb hai babalog?
ReplyDeletePlease discus the below question as well...
ReplyDeleteAccording to sanad granted to Raja of Sirmaur in 1815 AD which of area was returned to him. The Answer " Kiarda Dun" mentioned in HPPSC Answer key is wrong.
It was returned to him in sanad 79 in 1933. Please refer Full text of "A Collection Of Treaties, Engagements And Sanads Vol-i Relating To The Punjab , The Punjab States And Delhi"
https://archive.org/stream/in.ernet.dli.2015.206801/2015.206801.A-Collection_djvu.txt
The Sanad (Ifo. LXXVIII) granted to the Raja in 1815 conferred on
hiiir> and his heirs in perpetuity his ancient possessions, with the excep-
tion of the fort and pargana of Morni, which were made OTer to the
Mir of Eotaha to whom they had originally belonged : the Kiarda Dun,
which was restored (No. LXXIX) in 1833 on payment of a nazarana
of Rs. 50,000 : a tract of hill country to the north of the river Giri,
made over to the Rana of Reonthal: and the parganas of Jannsar and
Bawar, in the Dehra Dun district, annexed to the British dominions.
In the options Jannsar and
Bawar and Babar seems to be same area. Unable to find any independent reference to Babar. So to me this seems to be wrong questions.
Please share your insight
Kiarda Dun is the correct answer. Sanad was granted to Raja of Sirmaur in 1815 but because administrative reasons process dealyed and the area was returned back in 1833 on the payment of 50000 rs. Morni got independence earlier and parganas of Jannsar and Bawar were added in british dominions.
DeleteMian Govardhan Singh Page No 127 Last paragraph clearly mentioned that it was only Kiarda Dun returned while proposal of jaunsar & bawar were turned down.
Read it carefully page 128 first para same book, Kirada dun was passed to Raja by another sanad issued on 05 sep 1933 not by one in 1815.
DeleteWhat question say according to sanad granted to Raja of Sirmuar in 1815 which of territories were returned to him. Kiarada dun was annexed and returned on 1933. So question and answer stand wrong. No where it says kiarda dun handed over to raja in 1815.
DeleteSanad Granted and process begin but it wasn't returned due to administrative reasons and finally process completed in 1833 and again a sanad was granted. Jansar-Bawar were kept by british, morni got independence earlier.
Delete54 ST any chance??????
ReplyDeleteKhadu Bhai..kindly predict cut off...yr guess alwz correct...So plz
ReplyDeleteToda tribe is 100% in Tamil Nadu.I confirmed it from Census of India site and Kerala govts site too.......
ReplyDeleteCome on Man this is clear Todo Tribes live in Nilgiri plateau and it is spread in 3 states of Kerela, Karnataka and Tamilnadu. It is like that if Gujjars lives on the border areas of Himachal and J&K then we will not call that they live particularly in J&K only or Particularly in HP only. Toda tribes lives in all the 3 states I mentioned above.
DeleteSeries A Q 49 .........not mentioned about choosing the options ... Correct or not correct .....pls clarify khadubhai.pls
ReplyDeleteWrite the question ?
DeleteQ 49# consider the following statements about theosophical society....1...2...3...4... select your answer from the codes given below..... without mentioning about choosing correct or not correct statements.
DeleteIt was obvious that you have to consider all the statements and choose correct one. Answer Given by official Key is correct for this, so no problem in this question.
DeleteWhat about those questions in which one is asked to select the not correct statements.......... Anyhow I am going to file the objection.
DeleteGo ahead !
DeleteSir plz cut off predict...this time u not why sir?? Yr prediction alwz correct...So plz sir...
ReplyDeleteFRBM Act 2003 hai.
ReplyDeleteKhudabhai IAS plz explain about Reet Marriage in detail
ReplyDeleteKhadu bhai general ki merit kya rhegi ..mera score 69.25 h ..kya koi chance h
ReplyDeleteConstitution vests the executive power to whom...president or council of ministers...i think president is not real executive...prime minister is real executive..defacto executive..head of council of ministers...plz khadu bhai clarify
ReplyDeleteRefer laxmikant polity.... Or bare act
DeletePresident
DeleteArticle 53 and article 73
Deleteकट ऑफ 66 सामान्य वर्ग के लिए निर्धारित होगी।
ReplyDeleteक्योंकि अलाइड परीक्षा 2016 व् इस परीक्षा का कठिनाई व परीक्षा स्तर एकसमान था । अलाइड परीक्षा में 12* 20 =240 अभ्यर्थियों तक कट ऑफ 125 अंक था यानि 63 %.
इस परीक्षा का 63% =76 (120÷63%) हो रहा हैं ।
क्योंकि नकारात्मक अंक कटेंगे अतः 10 अंक कम हो जायेंगे क्योंकि 120-76= 44( 44÷4 =11) .
अतः अंतिम कट ऑफ 66-+1 (76-11) रहेगी ।
I have sent objection for 4 questions today
ReplyDelete1 FRBM act (source ..copy of act)
2 Sampriti ( PIB report of ministry of defence)
3 Godavari ( dakshin ganga) ncert class 9th
4 Doab region,banagr and influent drainge.. Ganga basin ( source UP text book,and wikipedia page ) bcoz both options are correct i.e . Indo Satluj and Ganga basin
Same objection brother .We are in same page and I agree completely with you regarding this.Kindly text me ur mobile no.
DeleteAnd one thing i also know that people say a lot of rubbish things here but when they have to send objections many of them show back and think some other will send and we will also get benefit.... And if there has to be a case filed then u will feel extreme peace and satisfactory environment
ReplyDeleteTomorrow I'm going to file 3 objections.
ReplyDelete.... Dakhshin ganga, Toda tribe and Annie Basent q 49 without mentioning the choices...
Dear Khadubhai Sir,
ReplyDeleteU have given a lot of explanations to make Cauvery the right ans.This is highly debatable cos in most of the books Godavari is Ganga of south.man! check out Gen studies book named Pratiyogita Darpan Geography(India & world),Ganga of south is Godavari.Since everyone knows repo of Renowned publishers Upkar publications & PD is referred by most of IAS aspirants n Toppers.So u must stay neutral in this case.Guys file as many objections regarding Godavary, else everyone who marked either of two must be given marks.Khadu Sir ur take abt cut off now people r waiting desperately.This blog is very good platform to share scores.
I agree with u.Although I have marked Kaveri as answer but the correct answer is Godavari and people should not be adamant to prove that Kaveri is the correct answer.
DeleteThe logics given by some friends are very strange .Pls think logically and just donot back your answers.
1st of all most of the guys not able to understand the two different terms and two different reasons or explanations. No body in denying Godavari is called Dakshin Ganaga but its a name not called or written Ganga of the South While we have evidences of Kavrei called Ganga of the South in India -Comprehensive Geography - D R Khullar and Tamilnadu State board Text books clearly mentions. Further I have no concerns if anybody want to send objections but believe me Commission don't publish these keys without solid authentic materiel. So i can bet this question will no be scraped. Answer is Kaveri and it will Stay.
Delete@ Anurag Logics are not enough I have provided you written evidences about Kaveri. It upto u guys to accept it or not. HPPSC will not change this answer. I can bet that.
DeleteKhadu Bhai how can u say that HPPSC doesn't publish answer without logic .
DeleteWhat has happened to Samrpiti question.
What has happened to FRBM question.
They are all human beings and they are bound to commit mistakes.Amd looking at the way u r backing Kaveri it seems you are concerned about only this particular question.You have not commented about the questions which are absolutely wrong as per keys.
FRBM and Samrpiti.
Your comments pls.
Dakshin Ganga,Ganga of Dakshin,Ganga of south,south ki Ganga ...all means one and same.The govt if India website itself says that answer is Godavari.I have filed Kaveri but I'm wrong and I m not that selfish that I wl back a wrong answer.
Thanks
Cut off ST category how much
ReplyDeleteToda tribe ????
ReplyDeleteBhai annie besant wale ques me kya galat hai ,,usko kyun challenge kar rha hai
ReplyDeleteBhai usme ye nhi bataya h ki correct statements choose karni h ya incorrect......mere anusar ye clear hona chahiye ki choose Kya karna h ....mere anusar statements 1&3 correct thi aur meine vahi choose ki .....ab answer key kuchh aur bata rahi h .....
ReplyDeleteAbe angrejon dakshin ganga aur ganges of the south me koi difference hai kya
ReplyDeleteSirf eng aur hindi ka fark hai
Ab ye btao jo banda hindi medium ka hai ya fir hindi me jo books publish hui hain ab chahe vi ncert hi kyun na ho ,,,usme kya GANGES OF SOUTH likha hoga
This ques will definitely got scraaped
When i was in coaching institute in vajiram,,,i asked from my teacher once,,,,he himself said that this is a doubtful ques and upsc never gonna ask this,,,,,,par hppsc to hppsc hai,,,,inhone jis book se bnaya hoga vahan cauvery diya hoga,,,,dusri book thodi na uthakar dekhte hain ye log
Air jinhone naib tehsildar lagna hai unko pta hai ki unko kaise lagna hai,,,,,,poori match fixing hai bhai
Mat lado aapas me
Aur is ques ko agar aap hindi wali side padho to wahan saaf saaf likha hai dakshin ki ganga
To ab ganga of south bolo ya fir ganges of south bolo ya fir dakshin ganga bolo ya fir dakshin ki ganga bolo koi fark ni padta hai
Aur khadu bhai to pta ni kya logic de rhe hain,,,aap upsc aspirant hain,,,aapse to ye umeed nahin hai
Aur jab ganga india ki river hai to fir ganga of south india bolo ya fir ganga of south ,,,,isse koi fark nahin padta ,,,,baat india ke south ki hai
Aur khadu bhai to states bhi gina rhe hain ki kahan se godavari behti hai ,,,aur vo to south india ka part nahin hai
Arey khadu bhai,,,,ek ganga north india me hai jo ki bhagirathi itself hai ,,,ab iske south me jo bhi hogi usko ganga of south bol sakte hain ,,,ye matter nahin karta ki tamilnadu me h ya kerela me hai
Hadd h tumhare logic ki bhi
Great .I agree completely with you.This is what I wanted to convey bhaiji.
Delete1st of all People need to know why they are called so ? Reason are both different and from the reasons we can draw the conclusions easily. I am applying logics. I am Giving authentic written evidences.
Delete1. DR Khullar - Indian Geography ( Drainage chapter)
2. Tamilnladu State Board text book 10th class. (Since Kaveri belongs to the extreme south no other source can be more authentic than Tamilnadu books They are highly recommended by UPSC exams across India).
Problem is that People those who have marked Godavari can send their objections Nobody is concerned about it. But the fact of the matter is these are not the same things. These are two different things having different reasons. If it would have been one thing then there would have been no confusion.
Nobody is deying that Goadvari is Dakshin Ganga but people are not able to understand the sublet difference in those and they are not considering the reasons for them calling by these names.
Kavrei is clearly Given in number of books Ganges of the South. Not in 1 book but in almost 10 books I have gone through while Godavri is mentioned Dakshina Ganga (not South Indian Ganga) in NCERT only.
Khadu Bhai a nice,gov.in ,ministry of India source ,ncert,pib etc are more authentic sources than any publishers.
DeleteI konw that it will be better if you tell this thing to those who are opening 1st page of google and drawing any conclusion. Quora, facebook, Blogs, twitter etc are not authentic sources. I have Given the links of NCERT, Tamilnadu State Board text Book (Tamil Nadu Govt) and a well reputed Geography author DR Khullar. But When Answering related to South Indian questions I will prefer Tamilnadu state board books because they are highly authentic very well researched. They are equally adopted for the preparations of UPSC exams across India.
DeleteOpen the wiki pages of godavari and cauveri separately,,,,, u will find dakshin ganga in godavari page
ReplyDeleteNowhere it is used for cauveri
Dear khadu Bhai can I have chance to appear in mains 68 Gen Category
ReplyDeleteBhaio in series b kaveri is given answer in official keys of commission...in other series may be printing mistake...kaveri is right..
ReplyDeleteKhadubhai ab to cutoff ki final prediction kr do .....Bhai .....
ReplyDeleteWith due respect khadubhai.....don't put emphasis on tamil nadu books....I know what the tamil people teach and what there mindset is ....exception are always there....u r downgrading ncert....even in upsc ncert prevails....and it should be norm...regionalism in our country is very well know ....so be struck to ncert....all know hkw has it eaten the fabric of our country....why people prefer cbi instead of sit....tamil nadu is not exception....more over even in upsc it known question are below 10 standard and mostly from ncert
ReplyDeleteNCERTs are full of lies. Just because NCERTs is widely studied does not mean that they are highly authentic. Does NCERTs teach us the correct History ? Not even 50 % of history by these NCERTs is correct. It is written by leftist historians and we know how, when and why this was done.
DeleteMoreover I am not giving one reference I have given multiple references and have proved my point. Now its up to you guys to accept the fact, I can't argue with anyone. I have no problem if someone sends objections. But it will be countered with solid references.
DeleteKhadubhai with due respect to you and your efforts ,without trying to undermine your knowledge I would like to put forward few points :
Delete1)Today tribe is found not in Nilgiri Hills but in Nilgiri District .The Nilgiri District is the only District that poses these tribes .The Nilgiri District is in Tamil Nadu and not in Kerala.For reference please visit nilgiris.nic.in the official site of Nilgiri District.
2)If NCERTs are full of lies then the IAS aspirants are committing a sin by reading these books .Kindly note IAS aspirants consider NCERT as bible for preparation and ok only refer to Tamil Nadu board for art and culture,ancient history part .Dakshin Ganga question being a geography question ,we can give NCERT more edge over Tamil Nadu Board.
3)The Jnaninpath award was given to Shanka Ghosh and not Shankar Ghosh.Shankar Ghosh is an instrumentalist.So technically this question may also be considered for scrapping
4)FRBM was passed in 2003 which was not in the option.
You are doing a great job khadubhai .
Thanks
वैदिककाल मे विशिष्ट अतिथियो के लिए गोमांस का परोसा जाना सम्मान सूचक माना जाता था।
Deleteकक्षा 6-प्राचीन भारत NCERT
लेखिका- रोमिला थापर
I am not saying NCERTs books are not Popular. They are Good, widely Used but full of lies and errors. NCERT are widely used because they covers the basic syllabus and UPSC follows them. Read ISCE Books they are far far better in both Quality and Authenticity. Just because anything is popular and widely accepted does not guarantee the quality and authenticity. And I have serious questions about the authenticity of NCERTs.
DeleteNCERT books full of errors -
HT
Class IX boy spots 7 errors in NCERT book, writes to HRD minister
‘NCERT books are dotted with disgraceful words, distorted history’
Factual mistakes and disputed historical references in school textbooks land the NCERT in trouble yet again
HRD Ministry faces flak over move to fix 'flaws' in NCERT History books
*ICSE Books
DeleteWith due respect khadubhai....Icse books give facts that are not required at each level.....more facts to learn....detailed knowledge burden on young minds...there is story of usa....people made mind to make accountable the municipal corporation to give them clean water...the water packedby company was costly and also unaccountable to safety standard....the people woh at last...rich and poor got clean water .....so cbse school you wana close...ncert you wana ban...do you give me guarantee that if Icse will be followed in large no. It won't be influenced....it too will be flaws and at even now it may have many flaws...it is just that it is not followed by masses....how much shift you will do...by the way history can be distorted but truth always prevails...accountability is needed....
Deletepeace guys... my first attemp and was second last chance... will be getting only 47 , gotta prepare more.. just started 3 months back and my hp gk is poor... Will see you in next exam...
ReplyDeleteConclusion is this,,,,,,,,ques of kaveri snd godavari is susceptible to create doubt and it must be challenged,,,,,fir hppsc pe depend krta h ki kya action lete hain,,,,,isi bahane future test ke liye bhi ye ques clear ho jaega,,,,kya pta HPAS ya allied me kabhi dobara mil jae
ReplyDeleteGuys after going through the above discussion the conclusion is that both godsvari and kaveri are right . Commission will give marks to both thats all
ReplyDeleteKhadu bhai plese clarify this: influent drainage, bangar soil , daob are the feature of indo-satluj plain or not
ReplyDeleteIndi satluj as it travel from tibet to hp or jk deposit large amount of kankars as it travel over the distance or more hilly regions. When u compare it with ganga it just has a very small kankar region . Ganga enter plain at haridwar and it originate frm gangotri.Ganga deposit kankar at a smaller path when u comapre it with indo satluj . So the right answer is indo satluj
Deleteare bhai chill kro sb.. doubts HPPSC ko bhej do jinko b hai jis b question me..yahna ldne se kuch ni hoga... HPPSC revised key me change krdegi if it feels doubts genuine hain to.. kr die to theek ..ni kie to court chle jana pr vahan b kuch ni hoga (Example-this year's UPSC case in SC was turned down).. to jinke 65 se upr bnre excluding doubts, mains ki tyari start kr lo.. ni b hoga clear to allied me kam ajaegi..
ReplyDeletegood 1
DeleteLeast.kandi....the day usool known the imp of discussion that day u will not give this comments....those discussed here countered will go in for long memory....it's more benefit....ase he selection of many institute don't keep discussion for fun....
DeleteDoab related to pujab region of pujab so ind satluj may be rt ans
ReplyDeleteSir as per wikipedia the meaning of Daob is a region lying between and reaching to the confluence of two rivers (esp. that between the Ganges and Jumna).
ReplyDeleteThere are many doabs in india . For eg cist, bist etc etc . Doab doest not necesarily means ganga
DeleteThat's why question have two answer
ReplyDeleteAgar unhone khadar pucha hota to ganga hota . Bhangar ke liye indi satluj
Deleteare koi hai jo is bar guess karega ki cut off kitni hogi category wise plz make prediction
ReplyDelete47 sc any chance to the candidate
ReplyDeleteCut off will be around
ReplyDeleteGeneral 62-65
SC 55
OBC 57
Bhai log HPAS Result ki hai koi khabar????????
ReplyDeleteWith in 1-2 days
ReplyDeleteBro how u know result will come with in 1-2days?
ReplyDelete